BITTER WINTER

Dutch Bill on Psychological Violence: A Risk for Religious Minorities

by | Nov 18, 2026 | News Global

A draft law meant to prevent femicides expressly extends to “closed groups,” and Parliament has asked that shunning in “cults” be punished.

by Massimo Introvigne

The permanent seat of the House of Representatives in The Hague, the institution that will discuss the bill. Credits.
The permanent seat of the House of Representatives in The Hague, the institution that will discuss the bill. Credits.

On June 29, 2026, Dutch Minister of Justice and Security David van Weel opened a public consultation on a bill that would make “coercive control” (“dwingende controle”) and psychological abuse criminal offenses. The consultation closed on September 7, and the government is now examining the comments before sending a text to Parliament.

Nobody can quarrel with the stated aim. According to figures quoted by Dutch media, femicide claims some forty-three lives a year in the Netherlands, and data released by Leiden University indicate that more than half of the women killed in the country between 2014 and 2024 died at the hands of a current or former partner. Many of these killings came after months or years of humiliation, surveillance, and isolation.

The core of the draft is a new Article 285aa of the Criminal Code, which reads: “Whoever, with the aim of exercising power over a person, systematically humiliates, frightens, restricts the freedom of, misleads, or otherwise systematically exerts influence on that person shall be punished with imprisonment of up to four years or a fine of the fourth category.” The prison term rises by one-third if the victim belongs to the perpetrator’s family circle. The explanatory memorandum notes that this maximum makes pre-trial detention and special investigative powers available, and no complaint from the victim is required. Article 300 on assault would be amended to cover damage to “physical or mental health,” an answer to the Dutch Supreme Court, which ruled on June 30 that abuse with no physical element falls outside the present provision. Finally, manslaughter “accompanied or preceded” by coercive control or domestic abuse could be punished like murder, with thirty years or life.

“Bitter Winter” shares the concern for women who live in fear at home, and for the children who grow up watching. Our worry is about the scope of the new crime. In its survey of foreign laws, the memorandum acknowledges that the Danish, English and Welsh, and Scottish provisions “require a certain perpetrator-victim relationship.” Section 76 of the Serious Crime Act 2015, in England and Wales, concerns behavior “in an intimate or family relationship.” The Scottish law of 2018 applies to partners and ex-partners.

These limits were deliberate. In Denmark, the 2019 bill that introduced the crime of psychological violence presented it as “a limited criminalization,” confined to close relationships where the perpetrator is connected to the victim’s household, a setting from which escaping is particularly hard, and recalled that other areas of life, such as the workplace, have rules of their own. In Scotland, the government’s Policy Memorandum reported that most of those consulted wanted the offense restricted to partners and ex-partners, since abuse within a couple has a dynamic of its own, and some feared that a wider scope would dilute the understanding of domestic abuse. The Explanatory Notes to the 2018 Act specify that relationships between friends, business partners, or work colleagues are left out.

In England and Wales, the question of “cults” was put directly to the government in 2026 by a group of former Scientologists, who asked for protection against coercive behavior outside domestic relationships. A letter of August 18, 2026, written on behalf of the Minister for Homelessness, Democracy, Communities and Faith and published by the petitioners, answered that the offense had been designed for people who are “personally connected,” that a wider one would create uncertainty for police and prosecutors. The Ministry wrote to the anti-cultists: “You specifically raise the legislative framework for controlling or coercive behaviour in relation to conduct outside domestic settings. The Government recognises that some campaigners and survivors have argued for extending protections to circumstances outside domestic relationships where coercive and controlling behaviours may also occur. However, the controlling or coercive behaviour offence was explicitly designed to address patterns of behaviour within relationships where the perpetrator and victim are ‘personally connected,’ as outlined in section 2 of the Domestic Abuse Act 2021. Expanding the offence beyond this context would risk undermining that clarity and creating uncertainty in the identification, investigation and prosecution of the offence. Therefore, there is no intention to expand the offence beyond its current scope at this time.”

Belgium and France, the Dutch memorandum adds, have no specific limitation to domestic relationships, but France is hardly a reassuring model, having in 2024 criminalized “psychological subjection” allegedly perpetrated by “cults.” The Dutch government chose the wider road. “The criminalization of coercive control,” section 3.3.4 of the memorandum states, “is not formulated in such a way that it applies only in specific relationships, such as (ex-)partner relationships.”

The same section explains where else the offense may apply: between parents and children, in the wider family, and beyond the home. “There is increasing attention,” it says, “for coercive control in groups of which the victim is a part.” The memorandum portrays “a closed group, in which a strong conviction exists and is propagated about how the world should look and how individuals who are part of the group ought to live.” In such groups, it continues, distrust of the outside world is fueled, members may be asked to break off contact with their loved ones, and “full loyalty” and “extreme investments of time and/or resources” are expected. The source cited for this portrait is a document on “coercive (closed) groups” published in April 2026 by Fier, the organization that runs “Onder Controle” (“Under Control”), a government-supported helpline for people leaving such groups. This dynamic, the government concludes, “can create a breeding ground” for coercive control. “All in all, coercive control is thus not limited to intimate relationships, so neither is the criminalization.”

These pages have a political history. For years, Socialist Party MP Michiel van Nispen has campaigned for tougher measures against what he calls “cults” (“sektes” in Dutch). In November 2024, he and Ingrid Michon-Derkzen of the liberal VVD obtained a motion asking the government to use the coming law on psychological violence to give better shape to its policy on “cults.” On June 30, 2025, State Secretary Teun Struycken answered with a letter to the House of Representatives on “insecurity and coercive control in (closed) groups,” reporting that the bill was being prepared and that psychological violence in “coercive groups” had been discussed with Fier. To his credit, Struycken recalled that freedom of religion and association oblige the state to restraint, and acknowledged that “sekte” is a word many perceive as negative.

Parliament went further. On September 9, 2025, the House adopted a second Van Nispen–Michon-Derkzen motion, whose very title asks that exclusion in “cults” be recognized as a punishable form of psychological violence. The target is the practice critics call “sociaal doodverklaren” (declaring somebody socially dead), better known as shunning, and the example usually offered in Dutch media is the Jehovah’s Witnesses.

Dutch Minister of Justice and Security David van Weel. Credits.
Dutch Minister of Justice and Security David van Weel. Credits.

The memorandum’s own examples show how far the text can travel. “Frightening” includes threats aimed “at the exclusion of the victim from the (closed) group to which the victim belongs.” Warning a wavering member about disfellowshipping or excommunication would fit. “Restricting freedom” covers prescribing “what and how much someone may eat, which clothing someone may or must wear,” and “with which persons someone may or may not associate.” Fasting rules, modest dress, and counsel about worldly company are the daily fabric of many faiths. “Misleading” means “presenting an untrue state of affairs,” which is how a secular prosecutor may view many religious doctrines. “Otherwise exerting influence” is presented as “a residual category” that “potentially includes a broad range of behaviors,” among them “subtle manipulations” persuading somebody to take distance from relatives, friends, work, or hobbies, and pressure to undergo or stop medical treatments.

The burden on the prosecution is light. According to the memorandum, “it need not be proven that the perpetrator’s behavior had a certain effect on the victim.” It is enough that the conduct was suited to produce it and was carried out with the aim of exercising power, an aim held to exist even if the suspect merely realized that power over the other would necessarily follow. Authority is exempted in the case of parents and court-appointed administrators, as long as it stays within what is acceptable “according to general societal standards.” Pastors, elders, and spiritual teachers are nowhere mentioned. Since no complaint is needed, a case could start while the supposed victims insist they are content with their faith. Argentina offers a cautionary tale, as prosecutors there read similar denials as evidence of how deeply the “victims” had been manipulated.

The amended Article 300 opens a second avenue, separate from coercive control. It requires neither a pattern of conduct nor the aim of exercising power. What must be proved is that the suspect intentionally damaged another person’s mental health, causing what the memorandum calls “a recognized psychiatric condition,” such as an anxiety or depressive disorder. Among the possible applications, the memorandum expressly lists “psychological violence in closed groups” in cases where the aim of exercising power required by Article 285aa is absent. A former member diagnosed with depression could thus accuse the leaders of a strict congregation of assault, even if nobody claims they sought power over that person.

The section of the memorandum on fundamental rights discusses Articles 2, 3, 7, and 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights. Freedom of religion, protected by Article 9 of the Convention and Article 6 of the Dutch Constitution, does not appear anywhere in the forty-two pages.

Readers of “Bitter Winter” may remember a paper I presented in Rome last July. I argued there that theories of “brainwashing,” rejected by most scholars of new religious movements and by courts of law in the last decades of the twentieth century, are coming back through three side doors: the extension of coercive control from couples to religions, the transformation of “spiritual abuse” into a legal category, and the use of anti-trafficking laws against spiritual groups. In the United Kingdom and in the Australian state of Victoria, activists and some politicians have asked that statutes on coercive control be stretched to cover “cults.” So far, trafficking and “spiritual abuse” are absent from the Dutch debate. The first door, however, is wide open.

Walking through it would be a mistake. Coercive control was studied and defined in the setting of the couple: two people, one home, shared money, daily physical proximity, and often a history of violence that makes every threat credible. The memorandum half-admits the difference, observing that the farther perpetrator and victim stand from each other, the easier it is for the victim to withdraw. A religious organization is precisely such a case. Its members joined or stayed as adults, live in their own houses, hold jobs, read newspapers, and leave in considerable numbers every year. To claim that the leaders of the Jehovah’s Witnesses exert over several million believers in the world the same control a violent husband has over his wife is to repeat the old “brainwashing” argument in a new vocabulary. The European Court of Human Rights observed in 2010, in a case won by the Jehovah’s Witnesses of Moscow against Russia, that there is no generally accepted and scientific definition of “mind control.” As for shunning, it consists of decisions by individual believers about the company they keep. In neighboring Belgium, a first-instance criminal conviction of the Jehovah’s Witnesses for this practice was overturned on appeal in 2022. On December 19, 2023, the Cassation closed the case with a final decision in favor of the Jehovah’s Witnesses. Courts in several other jurisdictions have reached similar conclusions.

The Netherlands has a long tradition of sheltering religious dissenters, and it can protect women without abandoning it. Four changes to the draft would remove the risk for religious minorities and take nothing away from the protection of victims of domestic violence. First, Article 285aa should apply to current and former partners and to members of the family or household, as the Danish, English, and Scottish models cited by the government do, for the reasons their own legislators gave. Second, the text of the law should state that religious teaching, worship, pastoral care, community discipline, and decisions about membership and association freely accepted by adults do not amount to coercive control, and the memorandum should remove the passages on “closed groups.” Third, the words “misleads” and “otherwise systematically exerts influence” should be deleted or precisely defined: the memorandum itself recalls that, under Article 7 of the European Convention, criminal provisions must be “sufficiently accessible, precise, and foreseeable,” a test that a self-described residual category can hardly pass. Fourth, the government should tell Parliament that the motion on exclusion cannot be carried out by sending believers to jail for choosing what they believe, no matter how unpopular, and whom they greet. Sexual abuse and violence committed inside a religious community are already crimes and should be prosecuted as vigorously as anywhere else.

Women in danger deserve protection. So do unpopular faiths against those who try to reintroduce, under any other name, the old pseudo-scientific idea that they convert their followers through “brainwashing.”


NEWSLETTER

SUPPORT BITTER WINTER

READ MORE