BITTER WINTER

Eight Suzuki, Fight Your Battles with Words. 3. The Courage to Correct a Mistake

by | Nov 16, 2026 | Testimonies Global

Judges may be starting to see through the anti-cult narrative, while lawyers hunt for new claimants and the dissolution order hurts thousands of believers.

by Eitaro Ogawa

Article 3 of 3. Read article 1 and article 2.

Attorney Tatsuki Nakayama (left) and author Eitaro Ogawa (right).
Attorney Tatsuki Nakayama (left) and author Eitaro Ogawa (right).

In the previous articles of this series, I argued that the claims of anti-cult journalist Eight Suzuki and attorney Masaki Kito about the enormous damage caused by the Family Federation for World Peace and Unification, formerly known as the Unification Church, are contradicted by the few hundred claimants who have come forward in the liquidation following the court-ordered dissolution of its religious corporation. I also discussed the September 16 acquittal of Tatsuki Nakayama, an attorney for the Family Federation whom Suzuki had accused of criminal insult over a blog post, and argued that disputes about words should be fought with words, without recourse to the courts.

One judgment alone does not justify firm conclusions. Yet Judge Nobuhiro Takamori’s ruling might suggest that the judiciary is beginning to recognize Suzuki’s true character.

After all, Suzuki has repeatedly directed extreme verbal abuse at Family Federation members, both on his blog and on X, formerly Twitter. On March 24, 2012, he posted: “Yes, indeed. The cockroaches inhabiting the cult are swarming. It must be breeding season. There’s no point dealing with people who are lower than cockroaches, so I’ll ignore them from here on. I’ve drawn out enough of their stupidity and exposed it more than adequately.”

On April 12, 2013, he wrote: “After Saga and Kumamoto, I hear that the Unification Church’s bogus spiritual medium, Dae Mo Nim, Kim Hyo-nam, is holding an event in Okinawa today. The scheme is to extract donations by supposedly summoning the spirits of dead religious founders and the like. And it’s not just her. All spiritual mediums are frauds, have the minds of infants, or are mentally ill.” “Dae Mo Nim” is an honorific religious title used in the Unification movement for Kim Hyo-nam.

These posts are more than ten years old, but Suzuki has made countless statements like this. And, as the quotations show, they offer no substantiation, no reasoning, and no real argument.

This explains why Nakayama, too, felt compelled to respond in the strongest possible terms.

Suzuki’s record of such statements can never be erased, and I suspect it formed part of the judgment’s background. As an unintended consequence of his own criminal complaint, the judiciary came to see what he is really like. This matters, because until now court cases involving the Family Federation have repeatedly ended in defeat for its side, as though the outcome had been decided in advance.

For example, the Family Federation sued Kito for defamation over statements he made on the TV show “Information Live Miyane-ya,” including his assertion that it “had made its members engage in prostitution.” In February 2025, the Tokyo High Court dismissed the claim, holding that the remarks “concerned an organization other than the Family Federation and did not diminish the Family Federation’s standing in society.” The Family Federation had submitted extensive evidence, including social media posts and comments on online news articles, showing that viewers understood the organization that “had made its members engage in prostitution” to be the Family Federation and no “other organization.” The High Court dismissed the claim anyway. I can only conclude that the outcome had been decided from the outset.

The defamation claim over the statement by journalist and politician Yoshifu Arita on the TV show “Sukkiri” that “the Family Federation is an antisocial group” was likewise dismissed. The Japanese expression “hanshakaiteki shūdan” describes a group acting against the norms and interests of society. Presumably, the judge had already assumed that Arita was a reasonable person and that the Family Federation was indeed an “antisocial group.”

After examining the court records, I found case after case involving the Family Federation dismissed out of hand based on such one-sided assumptions. This suggests that the judiciary has been thoroughly permeated by the idea, instilled through indoctrination, that the Family Federation is synonymous with a “cult.”

Against that backdrop, Judge Takamori’s ruling must have required considerable courage. I also see the prosecutors’ decision not to appeal, which made the acquittal final, as a sign that the tide is turning.

At this juncture, I particularly wish to draw attention to the activities of the National Network of Lawyers Against Spiritual Sales, led by Kito. Faced with so few claims, they fear their longstanding assertions will collapse and are desperately looking for victims. I repeat: now more than ever, the public must subject their activities to rigorous scrutiny.

On September 12, Kyodo News distributed a report headlined “‘Don’t Give Up’ on Redress for Donation-Related Harm: Consultation Session in Kyoto over the Former Unification Church.” It stated that “lawyers working to secure redress for victims explained the application procedures and urged participants, ‘Don’t give up just because you have no evidence.’” Five lawyers reportedly attended, yet only fifteen former members and relatives showed up.

What on earth does it mean for a lawyer to say, “Don’t give up just because you have no evidence”? What does this absence of evidence signify, if not that no actual harm occurred? Are these lawyers suggesting that, if there is no evidence, they will manufacture it themselves?

Let us draw a conclusion. The government and the courts were simply wrong to decide that the organization should be dissolved because it had harmed vast numbers of people.

The dissolution order itself is causing serious harm to the members. A survey of their circumstances had received 13,213 responses by October 3. Of the respondents, 84.7% reported psychological distress caused by the dissolution order. There were 3,724 reports of effects on physical health, 352 of consultations at psychosomatic medicine clinics, a Japanese medical specialty dealing with the interaction between psychological factors and physical symptoms, and 541 of hospital consultations.

The effects extended to every area of daily life: more than 2,000 reports of criticism or violence from family members or relatives, 462 distressing experiences at school or work, 19 believers questioned about their faith by teachers or counselors, and 44 instances of damage to their business. These figures come from the presentation by Family Federation President Masaichi Hori at the international conference of CESNUR, the Center for Studies on New Religions, held in Taiwan on October 12.

 President Masaichi Hori speaking at CESNUR 2026.
President Masaichi Hori speaking at CESNUR 2026.

Tragically, I have also heard that several people took their own lives after being overwhelmed by the shock of the dissolution.

Despite the appeals on television and the lawyers’ network’s extensive search, the number of claimants has remained in the low hundreds. That hollow figure bears no comparison with the suffering described above. The damage caused by the dissolution order rests on stark, lived realities, and belongs to an entirely different order from the exaggerated, false figures and unfounded assumptions advanced by Kito, Suzuki, and others.

First, I call on the Liberal Democratic Party to rescind its declaration that it would “sever ties” with the Family Federation. To exclude an organization that, in the thirty years before the assassination of former Prime Minister Shinzo Abe in 2022, had neither committed a criminal offense nor become a major social controversy is, quite simply, discrimination the Constitution does not allow.

Is the Family Federation being treated as a modern-day Buraku community? The Buraku are communities that were historically discriminated against under Japan’s former hereditary status system, and prejudice against people identified with them or their descendants has persisted, in marriage and employment among other areas.

The Liberal Democratic Party should take responsibility and bring to a decisive end the dissolution frenzy that began with television’s manipulation of public opinion in the turmoil following Abe’s assassination. Unless political and judicial authorities recover their consciences and correct their judgments, this issue is likely to keep generating a particularly pernicious business built around purported victims.

Individuals can now file claims themselves through the liquidator’s website. In practice, however, requests for advice are channeled to the Japan Legal Support Center, a public body providing legal information and legal aid known as Houterasu, and lawyers’ assistance in seeking refunds is being turned into a source of revenue. Moreover, a 2023 law, the Act on Special Provisions for Victims of Specified Tortious Acts (Act No. 89 of 2023), provides for Houterasu to advance lawyers’ fees and related expenses regardless of the applicant’s financial means. The money is paid upfront, which does not, by itself, mean repayment is waived.

If lawyers urge people not to “give up just because you have no evidence” with such a funding arrangement already secured, what is this if not a business built on victim redress?

The liquidation is supposed to end once the liquidator reasonably determines that measures to compensate the victims have been completed. If this business model is allowed to continue, the lawyers’ network might keep bringing forward victims in small batches, prolonging the liquidation for as long as possible.

Recently, at a public meeting, Kito went so far as to argue that membership lists should be used to find out who donated, when, and how much. Even at this stage, do they intend to approach large donors one by one and induce them to file claims, as they have done for years?

It is high time that Japanese society, including the governing Liberal Democratic Party and the judiciary, recognized what is really at stake. Is the Family Federation a “cult,” or have Suzuki and Kito departed from all bounds of reason?

Kito and Suzuki’s assertions about the nature and extent of the damage were utter fabrications.

It is never too late to correct a mistake. There is little point now in blaming those who were swept up in the atmosphere that followed Abe’s assassination and went along with the agenda of those who persuaded them that the Family Federation was a cult.

I call on the government, the governing parties, and the judiciary to show the courage and good sense needed to rectify the wrongful dissolution order through the legal means available.


NEWSLETTER

SUPPORT BITTER WINTER

READ MORE