• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer
  • HOME
  • ABOUT CHINA
    • NEWS
    • TESTIMONIES
    • OP-EDS
    • FEATURED
    • GLOSSARY
    • CHINA PERSECUTION MAP
  • FROM THE WORLD
    • NEWS GLOBAL
    • TESTIMONIES GLOBAL
    • OP-EDS GLOBAL
    • FEATURED GLOBAL
  • INTERVIEWS
  • DOCUMENTS AND TRANSLATIONS
    • DOCUMENTS
    • THE TAI JI MEN CASE
    • TRANSLATIONS
    • EVENTS
  • ABOUT
  • EDITORIAL BOARD
  • TOPICS

Bitter Winter

A magazine on religious liberty and human rights

three friends of winter
Home / From the World / News Global

Oak Flat Apache Site: Destruction Can Proceed, 9th Circuit Says

06/29/2022Massimo Introvigne |

Another legal round goes against the Native Americans. Without a Supreme Court or political intervention, the sacred site appears to be doomed.

by Massimo Introvigne

Activists protesting at the Oak Flat site. From Twitter.
Activists protesting at the Oak Flat site. From Twitter.

Bitter Winter publicized in 2021 the story of Oak Flat, in Arizona, called by the Apaches Chi’chil Bildagoteel, and regarded as one of their sacred sites. It is destined to disappear as a consequence of a land swap opening the way to one of the larger copper mines in the world, which will “swallow” Oak Flat.

Then President Obama and the Congress authorized in 2014 the deal, which will benefit Resolution Copper, a joint venture between mammoth multi-national companies BHP and Rio Tinto. The Apaches, however, claim that destroying a sacred religious site would violate their religious liberty.

On February 12, 2021 a federal District Court in Arizona ruled against the Apaches and allowed work to commence on March 6. The following month, however, the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) withdrew its Final Environmental Impact Statement, which it had released on January 15, 2021, and which was crucial for authorizing the copper mine project to go on, pending the Apaches’ appeal.

Now, the 9th Circuit has decided on June 24, 2–1, that the project does not violate the Apaches’ freedom of religion. The majority stated that “the government imposes a substantial burden on religion,” prohibited by the Religious Freedom Restoration Act, “in two—and only two—circumstances.”

This happens when the government “force[s citizens] to choose between following the tenets of their religion and receiving a governmental benefit,” and when the government “coerce[s citizens] to act contrary to their religious beliefs by the threat of civil or criminal sanctions.” In this case the government did not impose any specific behavior on the Apaches, the judges argued, and losing their place of worship is just a side effect of a decision taken on other grounds.

Dissenting opinion: Judge Marsha Berzon. From Facebook.
Dissenting opinion: Judge Marsha Berzon. From Facebook.

Judge Marsha Berzon dissented, finding that, “The majority applies an overly restrictive test for identifying a ‘substantial burden’ on religious exercise under the Religious Freedom Restoration Act…. The majority’s flawed test leads to an absurd result: blocking Apaches’ access to and eventually destroying a sacred site where they have performed religious ceremonies for centuries does not substantially burden their religious exercise. The majority offers both a doctrinal and a practical basis for its unduly narrow definition of ‘substantial burden.’ Both are incorrect.”

The Apaches may now take their case to the Supreme Court. How politics will react will also be interesting. The climate in the United States favors extensive definitions of religious liberty. But is this true even when religious liberty is asserted to stop an economic project worth billions?

Tagged With: Native Americans, United States of America

Related articles

  • United States: Will the Anti-Catholic “Blaine Amendments” Go?

    United States: Will the Anti-Catholic “Blaine Amendments” Go?

  • California and Confession. 4. Confessing to More than One Minister

    California and Confession. 4. Confessing to More than One Minister

  • China, The Worst Offender: The 2022 U.S. Department of State Report on Religious Freedom

    China, The Worst Offender: The 2022 U.S. Department of State Report on Religious Freedom

  • Why the Indiana Payne-Elliott Decision Is Good for Religious Liberty

    Why the Indiana Payne-Elliott Decision Is Good for Religious Liberty

Keep Reading

  • Amish May Refuse Septic Tanks for Religious Reasons: US Supreme Court
    Amish May Refuse Septic Tanks for Religious Reasons: US Supreme Court

    Freedom of religion exemption apply to a refusal to comply with state sewage laws based on a refusal of modern technology.

  • “White Is Also a Color”: CCP Blames Protests on American Conspiracy
    “White Is Also a Color”: CCP Blames Protests on American Conspiracy

    The Party believes it has successfully prevented a U.S.-instigated “color revolution” in China. It is also replacing the word “COVID-19” with “coronavirus cold.”

  • California and Confession. 3. With Relatives Present, It’s Still a Confession
    California and Confession. 3. With Relatives Present, It’s Still a Confession

    In other American states, courts have concluded that the presence of wives, children, or parents of the penitent does not make the confessional privilege inapplicable.

  • James Huntsman’s Anti-Mormon Lawsuit Fails
    James Huntsman’s Anti-Mormon Lawsuit Fails

    Court states billionaire James Huntsman, who left the Latter-day Saints Church, is not entitled to receive his donations back.

Primary Sidebar

Support Bitter Winter

Learn More

Follow us

Newsletter

Most Read

  • Blaming the Victims: The Hamburg Shooting and the Jehovah’s Witnesses by Massimo Introvigne
  • The Donnie Yen Fiasco: A Uyghur View by Rebiya Kadeer
  • Abduxaliq Uyghur, 1901–1933: Uyghurs Remember Their Beheaded Poet by Abdurehim Gheni Uyghur
  • The “Buddhist and Taoist Clergy Database,” Another CCP Imposture by He Yuyan
  • The Suicide of the Pink-Haired Girl: How the CCP Exploited a Tragedy by Zhou Kexin
  • Second-Generation Unification Church Believers Discriminated in Japan. 1. A Tale of Two Petitions by Masumi Fukuda
  • Second-Generation Unification Church Believers Discriminated in Japan. 3. Media Slander Leads to Discrimination by Masumi Fukuda

CHINA PERSECUTION MAP -SEARCH NEWS BY REGION

clickable geographical map of china, with regions

Footer

EDITORIAL BOARD

Editor-in-Chief

MASSIMO INTROVIGNE

Director-in-Charge

MARCO RESPINTI

ADDRESS

CESNUR

Via Confienza 19,

10121 Turin, Italy,

Phone: 39-011-541950

E-MAIL

We welcome submission of unpublished contributions, news, and photographs. Each submission implies the authorization for us to edit and publish texts and photographs. We reserve the right to decide which submissions are suitable for publication. Please, write to INFO@BITTERWINTER.ORG Thank you.

Newsletter

LINKS

orlir-logo hrwf-logo cesnur-logo

Copyright © 2023 · Bitter Winter · PRIVACY POLICY· COOKIE POLICY