• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer
  • HOME
  • ABOUT CHINA
    • NEWS
    • TESTIMONIES
    • OP-EDS
    • FEATURED
    • GLOSSARY
    • CHINA PERSECUTION MAP
  • FROM THE WORLD
    • NEWS GLOBAL
    • TESTIMONIES GLOBAL
    • OP-EDS GLOBAL
    • FEATURED GLOBAL
  • INTERVIEWS
  • DOCUMENTS AND TRANSLATIONS
    • DOCUMENTS
    • THE TAI JI MEN CASE
    • TRANSLATIONS
    • EVENTS
  • ABOUT
  • EDITORIAL BOARD
  • TOPICS

Bitter Winter

A magazine on religious liberty and human rights

three friends of winter
Home / From the World / Featured Global

Inside The Revelation Spiritual Home. 4. Opposition

02/16/2023Massimo Introvigne |

The Commission for the Promotion and Protection of the Rights of Cultural, Religious and Linguistic Communities (CRL) produced in 2017 a strange anti-cult (and anti-TRSH) report.

by Massimo Introvigne and Rosita Šorytė

Article 4 of 4. Read article 1, article 2, and article 3.

The 2017 CRL report criticizing The Revelation Spiritual Home and several other groups, and CRL’s then chairperson, Thoko Mkhwanazi-Xaluva (from Twitter).
The 2017 CRL report criticizing TRSH and several other groups, and CRL’s then chairperson, Thoko Mkhwanazi-Xaluva (from Twitter).

Successful spiritual movements normally have enemies. While during our visit to The Revelation Spiritual Home (TRSH) we regarded most of what we saw as admirable, and noted how devotees voted with their feet continuing to attend the services in massive numbers, what we found in South African media about the movement was often critical, and reminiscent of anti-cult stereotypes we were all familiar with, used to slander movements labeled as “cults” in Europe, Eastern Asia, and North America.

We were all aware that not all spiritual movements play a positive role (I have coined myself the expression “criminal religious movements,” noting that they exist among both “old” and “new” religious traditions). South Africa is no exception, and the media there are happy to reports incidents where self-styled prophets persuade their followers to eat grass or engage in other forms of bizarre behavior.

Religious abuse also exists in mainline churches, as evidenced by the pedophilia scandals in the Catholic Church and other large institutions. Abuse is certainly not protected by religious liberty. However, it is an entirely different matter when governments try to take advantage of the abuses and use them as a pretext to impose a generalized control on minority religious and spiritual organizations, or deprive them of their tax-exempt status. Not surprisingly, governments are always interested in extending their control and raising more taxes.

While in other parts of the world campaigns against minority religions are carried out according to the ideology of the so-called anti-cult movement, South Africa has a special history. The infamous apartheid policy also included a spiritual apartheid. Christian and other mainline churches were regarded as “legitimate.” Those established by Africans were called “independent” (a label that is today regarded as derogatory) and “problematic.” African indigenous spirituality was slandered as “witchcraft” and even as “demonic.”

The mokhuku male choir dancers of Zion Christian Church, one of the largest groups once labeled an “African independent church.” Source: World Religions and Spirituality Project.
The mokhuku male choir dancers of Zion Christian Church, one of the largest groups once labeled an “African independent church.” Source: World Religions and Spirituality Project.

The African elite that replaced the white government in South Africa had been mostly educated according to a Western paradigm (or in Marxist universities in the Soviet Union), and shared a prejudice against non-mainline religion, if not against religion in general. We often heard from TRSH and other non-mainstream religionists the comment that “in matters of religion the black government is anti-black.” Conversely, members of the professional and political elite may be disturbed by beliefs and rituals they see as backward and an obstacle on South Africa’s path to become a modern regional political and economic power armed with cutting-edge technology.

In 2002, the Commission for the Promotion and Protection of the Rights of Cultural, Religious and Linguistic Communities (CRL) was established as an independent institution under Chapter Nine of the South African Constitution. In 2015 it decided, somewhat arbitrarily, that its mandate extended to checking whether religious institutions were beneficial or harmful to South African communities. It started holding hearings on “the commercialization of religion and abuse of people’s belief systems,” on which in 2017 it produced a report.

The terminology itself showed the influence of European and American anti-cult ideology. The commission and its chairperson, Thoko Mkhwanazi-Xaluva, candidly admitted in the report that they had originally taken their information from “controversial news reports and articles in the media.” Not only in South Africa, media bias against minority spiritual groups is well-known to scholars of the field.

CRL Rights Commission members with then South African President Jacob Zuma in 2017. From Facebook.
CRL Rights Commission members with then South African President Jacob Zuma in 2017. From Facebook.

The CRL expressed its concern about “false churches” (without clarifying how a “false” church can be distinguished from a “true” one) and claims by spiritual leaders to an authority they did not in fact possess. Again, which standards the CRL required to “prove” spiritual authority was unclear. The CRL also wanted religious and spiritual organizations to disclose to the commission their budgets and bank accounts.

As the leader of one of the fastest-growing spiritual movements in South Africa, IMboni was summoned to appear and bring TRSH’s accounts. He refused, claiming that the investigation and the requests were against the South African Constitution, and went to present his complaints against the CRL to the Parliament. As a result, Mkhwanazi-Xaluva depicted IMboni as rebellious and created a media campaign against him. She also accused a member of TRSH of having insulted and tried to intimidate her. She managed to have the man sentenced, but her attempts to have IMboni himself incriminated failed.

IMboni embraces a child during a Tuesday healing service. Photo by Massimo Introvigne.
IMboni embraces a child during a Tuesday healing service. Photo by Massimo Introvigne.

The aim of the CRL was to create a system of state control of religion, which would be unprecedented in democratic countries. The final report suggested legislation under which all religious and spiritual organizations should have leaders (with a temporary exception for founders) and treasurers democratically elected by the members (obviously, this does not happen in mainline organizations such as the Catholic Church, where the bishop is not elected by the church members).

All religious and spiritual organizations, the CRL proposed, should affiliate themselves with umbrella organizations, which would in turn be under the supervision of “peer-review committees” established for each religious tradition (Christians, African Religion, Muslims, Jews, Hindus, Rastafari) that would report to the CRL Commission itself. Individual religious practitioners and places of worship should also be registered with one of the CRL-supervised umbrella organizations. As the report clearly stated, “the CRL Rights Commission will remain the final arbiter in all matters” concerning religion and spirituality.

When I first read the report, my immediate reaction was, “Where did I see all this before?” I happen to be a scholar of religion in China, and this is precisely the Chinese system. In China, there is a centralized administration of religious affairs, and five umbrella organizations (for Protestants, Catholics, Muslims, Buddhists, and Taoists), to which all religious groups should belong. Those that refuse to become part of one of the umbrella organizations are declared illegal and persecuted.

A few weeks ago, the U.S. Commission for International Religious Freedom (USCIRF) joined many others institutional and scholarly voices in denouncing the Chinese system of the mandatory umbrella organizations as a tool of oppression and an egregious violation of religious liberty. It would be a scandal if a democratic country such as South Africa would adopt the Chinese model. So far, the government has agreed that the CRL’s recommendation should in fact not be adopted. But the fight is not over.

Are there black sheep in the world of South African religion and spirituality? Yes, as everywhere else. But when they commit crimes, these may be punished by using the existing laws, without the need of putting all religious and spiritual organizations under a totalitarian state control.

TRSH devotees at the Empandeni branch Sunday service. Photo by Massimo Introvigne.
TRSH devotees at the Empandeni branch Sunday service. Photo by Massimo Introvigne.

As for TRSH, scholars who study South African new religions often share the prejudices of the local establishment. Sometimes, scholars of new religious movements from abroad may contribute a different look. Yet, I agree with Matthew Wilhelm-Solomon when he wrote in 2013 in his chapter for “Writing Invisibility: Conversations on the Hidden City” (a book published by the Johannesburg “Mail & Guardian,” a newspaper that has published itself slanderous articles against TRSH), that to reduce the success of the movement to “commercialization” of spirituality is just “too simple.”

If TRSH is successful, the scholar wrote, it is because “It speaks to a hope that the failed aspirations of the city can be restored, that its pollutants can be cleansed, and that the people and things lost in its streets will return safely home, wherever that may be.”

Tagged With: South Africa, The Revelation Spiritual Home

Massimo Introvigne
Massimo Introvigne

Massimo Introvigne (born June 14, 1955 in Rome) is an Italian sociologist of religions. He is the founder and managing director of the Center for Studies on New Religions (CESNUR), an international network of scholars who study new religious movements. Introvigne is the author of some 70 books and more than 100 articles in the field of sociology of religion. He was the main author of the Enciclopedia delle religioni in Italia (Encyclopedia of Religions in Italy). He is a member of the editorial board for the Interdisciplinary Journal of Research on Religion and of the executive board of University of California Press’ Nova Religio.  From January 5 to December 31, 2011, he has served as the “Representative on combating racism, xenophobia and discrimination, with a special focus on discrimination against Christians and members of other religions” of the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE). From 2012 to 2015 he served as chairperson of the Observatory of Religious Liberty, instituted by the Italian Ministry of Foreign Affairs in order to monitor problems of religious liberty on a worldwide scale.

www.cesnur.org/

Related articles

  • Inside The Revelation Spiritual Home. 2. A Fast-Growing Spiritual Movement

    Inside The Revelation Spiritual Home. 2. A Fast-Growing Spiritual Movement

  • Inside The Revelation Spiritual Home. 1. The Path of IMboni

    Inside The Revelation Spiritual Home. 1. The Path of IMboni

  • Rastafarians: South Africa “Private Marijuana” Bill Fails to Cover Religious Use

    Rastafarians: South Africa “Private Marijuana” Bill Fails to Cover Religious Use

  • Inside The Revelation Spiritual Home. 3. Walking on Two Legs, African Indigenous Spirituality and Economic Empowerment

    Inside The Revelation Spiritual Home. 3. Walking on Two Legs, African Indigenous Spirituality and Economic Empowerment

Keep Reading

  • Human Rights Watchdogs Urge EU to Review Its Relations with Pakistan
    Human Rights Watchdogs Urge EU to Review Its Relations with Pakistan

    A conference in Brussels called the attention on the intolerable situation of human rights and freedom of religion or belief in the Asian country.

  • Did French Diplomacy Support an Anti-Cult Extremist Who Calls Buddhists and LDS “Cultists”?
    Did French Diplomacy Support an Anti-Cult Extremist Who Calls Buddhists and LDS “Cultists”?

    Argentinian Pablo Salum includes among “cultists” even the Catholic Discalced Carmelite nuns. He claims that in 2013 he was offered collaboration by the French Embassy.

  • Religious Liberty in the World in 2023: Worse Than Ever
    Religious Liberty in the World in 2023: Worse Than Ever

    USCIRF 2023 Annual Report shows serious regression in several countries and a few new entries. In China and Russia, minorities continue to be persecuted.

  • The Great Cult Scare in Argentina and the Buenos Aires Yoga School. 1. Raiding an Old Ladies’ Cafe
    The Great Cult Scare in Argentina and the Buenos Aires Yoga School. 1. Raiding an Old Ladies’ Cafe

    On August 12, 2022, fully armed SWAT team police raided a cafeteria and some fifty private homes of students of what they claimed was a criminal “cult.”

Primary Sidebar

Support Bitter Winter

Learn More

Follow us

Newsletter

Most Read

  • Chinese Muslims Told Mosques Should Preach Communism Too by Ma Wenyan
  • Hebei: Friends Pray in Your Home, the CCP Cuts Off Your Water and Electricity by Lai Mingxia
  • China’s “Query System for Islamic, Catholic, and Christian Clergy,” Another Tool for Repression by He Yuyan
  • Christian Students Asked to Study 20th Congress and Celebrate “Heroes” Who Betrayed the Church by Zhang Chunhua
  • Russia: Two Evangelical Pastors Prosecuted, Falsely Accused of Raising Money for the Ukrainian Army by Massimo Introvigne
  • Filipino Catholic Priest Arrested for Slandering Unrecognized Marian Apparitions by Massimo Introvigne
  • Pakistan, Young Christian Sentenced to Death for Blasphemy by Massimo Introvigne

CHINA PERSECUTION MAP -SEARCH NEWS BY REGION

clickable geographical map of china, with regions

Footer

EDITORIAL BOARD

Editor-in-Chief

MASSIMO INTROVIGNE

Director-in-Charge

MARCO RESPINTI

ADDRESS

CESNUR

Via Confienza 19,

10121 Turin, Italy,

Phone: 39-011-541950

E-MAIL

We welcome submission of unpublished contributions, news, and photographs. Each submission implies the authorization for us to edit and publish texts and photographs. We reserve the right to decide which submissions are suitable for publication. Please, write to INFO@BITTERWINTER.ORG Thank you.

Newsletter

LINKS

orlir-logo hrwf-logo cesnur-logo

Copyright © 2023 · Bitter Winter · PRIVACY POLICY· COOKIE POLICY